15 Minutes

Financial, Relationship and Spiritual Growth. Personal Development. Leadership.

Correction: Pelf

4 Comments

mirrorBack in February I posted a poem by Dale Wimbrow called The Guy in the Glass. I preceded it with a little note about how I had always thought that the poem was called The Man in the Glass or The Man in The Mirror. Negative, the proper title is The Guy in the Glass. I know this because I found a website, created by the children of the author that has the poem in it’s entirety along with some info about it.

When I posted the poem to my own site, I noticed something which appalled me greatly. A spelling error. I am a little bit of a grammar-Nazi apparently (despite my inappropriate use of dashes and semi-colons in my own writing), but this distressed me greatly.

One, because this was a site established to honor the author of a timeless piece of poetry by his children, so they should have been more careful.

Two, because this was a poem, not a novel. In a short literary piece such as this, every word is important, and messing up one of them is just… icky. Especially in the first line!

So, even though I cut and pasted the poem from the source site and reprinted on my blog, I corrected it.

Here is the original line:
“When you get what you want in your struggle for pelf,”

This caused me to cringe, and being eagerly grammaticious, I changed it to:
“When you get what you want in your struggle for self,”

Because everyone knows that pelf is not a word, right?

Right?

I found out much, much later, and for the life of me I can’t remember where I learned it, “pelf” is an actual word.

The definition of pelf according to dictionary.com is “money or wealth, especially when regarded with contempt or acquired by reprehensible means.”

(Insert face in palm)

So there are a few lessons to be learned here.

  1. Be willing to question your core beliefs. Just because you have always believed something does not make it true. I was absolutely sure that pelf is not a real word. Look at it! “Pelf”? It’s like a made-up children’s word for their pet elf.
  2. The majority is not always correct. Just because everyone else believes it, doesn’t make it any more true. If you do a Yahoo! search for “Man in the Glass” (which is the incorrect title) you will see that the top three results re-post the poem “corrected” in the same manner that I corrected it: wrong. Consensus does not equal truth.
  3. Whenever possible, get your information from the original source. It’s like that party game “telephone.” The more ears and mouths a piece of information goes through, the more likely it is to be wrong.

So, I apologize to Dale Wimbrow and his children. Also, I apologize to my readers for my part in spreading out additional disinformation on the world wide web. My Grammar Ninja merit badge has been rescinded.

I do have a question for everyone though. What is a good, accurate site to go to to verify quotes?

Advertisements

Author: Matt_S_Law

Matt S. Law is an author focusing on success principle and motivational books. He was born, raised and currently resides in Honolulu, Hawaii.

4 thoughts on “Correction: Pelf

  1. Pingback: The Guy in the Glass | 15 Minutes

  2. I’ve noticed that quotes do vary from site to site, so I can’t recommend one. I actually use a couple of quotation reference books. They’re very well-thumbed but perhaps a little dated. You can usually pick them up cheaply in second-hand bookstores.

  3. Dear Mat,
    I read your post and have a question that I’d like to see if you can help me with. I didn’t know who “Jack Horner” was ( in the fourth stanza of the poem), and when I Googled it, the only reference I found is that of a paleontologist who was born in 1946. For obvious reasons, I don’t think he referred to this man, as he was born 14 years after Wimbrow wrote his poem. Is there any other interpretation for Jack Horner?
    Thanks a lot!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s